chelsea, have you tried this, when ds is asleep for a nap have you stood by his cot the whole time and as soon as he stirs a bit start the shh/pat then, do this for his whole nap time and for a number of days afterwards, later if you can predict his stirs time then go there a few minutes before hand and shh/pat again, i did this, i used a timer to the second, sounds a bit over the top but it worked for us, you said you did wake to sleep and he woke 5 minutes later, when i was sleep training dd always woke 5 minutes after i resettled her, it wasn't until i stood by her bed and continue with the shh/pat that i was finally able to get her to sleep longer, and i must add that she woke many time in a row of 5 minutes, sorry i just can't remember what you have said about shh/pat in the past, also do your own type of shh/pat, it might be gentle talking and rubbing of the face, what ever, i really do hope that you have a better day today