Hi Vally
Sorry you didn't get any replies yet, I'm not sure how we missed your post.
Your EASY is looking good
- should I try and stop the 5pm feed and make him wait until 630pm even though he's pretty hungry at 5pm and usually has 4oz?
I would keep it in there. It is 3hrs since the previous E and he is likely ready to eat. It's fine to have the BT E less than the 3 hrs, often we call it "tanking up" or "cluster feeding" when they come close together like that. I always worked feeds at 3hrs through the day but always gave the BT feed at whatever time BT was regardless of it it had been 30 mins or an hour or 3hrs since the previous feed. Sometimes they take it like a top up before the night sleep (so taking less than a full feed but it still fills them up, looks like yours is doing this) and sometimes they will still take a full feed even though they not long had one because they just know it's BT (mine did this, BT feed was always big even if less than 3hrs). So, no problems there.
- am I creating a problem using Paci as I wander if this is why he wakes at 530am or do you just think he's had enough sleep by then? Should I be trying to get him to sleep without Paci
It really depends what you call a problem. Paci use has some benefits and many people want LO to take a paci, others don't. Yes it can be habit forming, but so can taking him into your bed at 5.30am. It doesn't mean you can't do those things but be prepared further down the line that if you set habits now you might not like them later. You can tackle habits if/when you decide you've had enough of him coming into your bed at 5.30am, if that's now then yes go ahead and resettle him in his cot.
Do you think he might be hungry at 5.30am? It's just that he might be finding it hard to get through from the NF at 3am all the way up to 6.30/7am for the WU feed. I would maybe try a quick NF and see if he just goes back off in his own bed, like you do for the other NFs. I know he does a good long stretch from BT to 12midnight but LOs only really do one long stretch between E over night.
- is there any further advice you can give on our current Easy for his age?
It looks like things are working well for you
You've managed to work naps around the school runs which is great and looks like there are some longish naps happening too
I think the only thing that catches my eye is that it is quite a long A time before BT at 2hr to 2hr 30min or longer if the nap ends up a bit short. You might consider another CN in there at 6 for say 30 - 40 min and that takes BT a little later more like 7.30/8pm. He might go for the CN and later BT and that *might* move his night feeds a little later and shift that 5.30am WU to more like 6.30am. Or he might do what many do which is refuse an evening CN.
It's up to you really, you could give it a go for a few days and see what happens.
Personally I would try it to see because I know I hated the 5am/5.30am WU, but if there is a huge fight against taking an evening CN there isn't much point spending a long time and lots of effort and frustration trying to make him sleep then.
hope this helps you