Thanks for the response! What FINALLY worked was a variation of W2S. At the 30 minute mark, I'd go into his room and wait for the tell-tale wakeup signs, which was lifting the legs and grunting. All I do is hold them down and leave my hand on his chest. I occasionally pat my hand lightly to get him back on track if his head starts weaving back and forth. I shush sometimes too, but I do have a little machine that plays white noise, although I don't think it's loud enough.
He is swaddled, but I'm starting to wean so I am leaving one hand out so he can suck on his fingers if he wants to. He's a jolter and that wakes him up but basically I wait for his eyelids to get heavy again and the big jolts to stop...after probably 15 minutes or so I just sit in the room, he still might jolt but his eyes close right away again.
He goes to bed OK, although that was not the case for a while (OT). He used to not cry at all but now he does this mantra cry that isn't really crying. So I swaddle, hold for maybe a minute and tell him he's going to sleep and how lucky he is, etc, etc and put him down in his crib. He's usually out within a few minutes and then I leave the room.
Naps today have only been 1.5 hours so I'm happy with that. Of course my routine didnt' work as planned last night - he did do the catnap but he was SOOO not ready for bed at 8:00. He didn't sleep until 9:15 so we didn't do a DF last night.
We are still trying to implement DF (day 5 today) and not sure if it's working. He still wakes regardless but I THINK he's not as hungry. Anyways, I digress!
Yeah, that's what I kinda thought about the 3.5 hour feedings. I can't wait until he can do longer A times - I still think he's a bit OT when I put him down (b/c we have more 30 min naps than 45 min ones) but it's hard to judge sometimes.
No props - he uses a paci but not all the time. He's been in his crib from about day 5 so no problems there. It's darkened too - not totally but I think it helps.
If I leave him to try and fall asleep by himself he'll eventually start to cry so, no, when he wakes he usually just opens his eyes and looks around. I get big smiles too, when I go in, but yawns too, so I know he's still tired.
I guess I just have to wait it out and see if he eventually gets the hang of it. I wanted to have it nipped by the end of July when we go camping but that just may not be the case!!
Thanks again!