Y'know, we got BW to (mostly) work for us with Josie, and when Nat came along she was the free-est spirit EVER from the get-go. Tummy sleeper, early crawler (5 months on her hands and knees, fast as lightning!
), gave up naps altogether (except for when sick or in the car) around 18 months
, and no matter WHAT we tried, no two days were EVER the same with her sleep-wise, probably for the first year and a half OR MORE. Seriously. I spent OVER TWO WEEKS trying pat/shh when she was a baby, and she's WAY too spirited to handle PU/PD so I didn't even bother.
She woke at different times, napped at different times, different nap lengths, different numbers of naps per day. There was no way I could work out a routine, no way she'd go for nap extensions, nothin'. I finally had to say "whatever" and APOP so I could spend some time with poor Josie, who was tired of waiting and waiting and waiting all alone for her sister to sleep already.
With Josie we knew reflux was a factor, and once we got it treated, things got better, but Nat didn't have that excuse. She was just too busy to sleep!
You're not a bad mom at all - you're following your LO! We'll be happy to check out your routine, of course, but PLEEEEASE don't spend time and energy beating yourself up.