I think it depends on whether or not eating at the table is going to be important to you later on down the road. All eating takes place at the table for everyone in the house and has since Tyler started solids. We have brand new carpet and a white couch, so roaming with food is not an option. But if you're comfortable with a bit more latitude, then do what feels right. It's pretty normal to go through phases of resisting restraint, whether it's the highchair, carseat, or stroller, but we just held firm and kept in mind that Tyler wouldn't starve himself. HTH!