Monika,
Thanks for the reply. We had a MUCH better day today. I am feeling like giving the paci back was a really good choice for me and my family. Today we just stayed home, it was supposed to snow a lot and didn't, and just played and watched for cues to see what he did naturally. He seemed pretty happy with a 3-3.5 schedule. He took a one hour morning nap, 1.5 hour afternoon nap, then a monster 2.5 hour nap from 1:30-4, and lastly a catnap at 5. We both fell asleep again at the breast at bedtime, but I can work on that. I did the df at 10:30 as you suggested and we'll see how tonight goes. He went 7 hours between feeds last night, but needed the paci put back in 4 times between 2:30-4am. Moving the df up makes a lot of sense.
I will let you know how things worked out.
Thanks,
Michelle