Yes, usually paci (I hate to admit it) but he does also settle if I just give him a ssh/pat. BTW, last night was much better. Awake only at 1:30, 3:45 and then at 5:15. I gave him the pact the first 2 times and he went right back to sleep. I think some of the wakings are hunger, especially the 5 ish feeding. Crazy thing I did last night, when he woke at 3:45, I turned off his night light and he went right back to sleep (a common time for him to wake over and over). I'm going to try keeping the night light off tonight too. Sounds crazy but I also realized I never have the night light on until his dream feed.
Also, in defense of the paci, I started to think it was that too but he tends to fall asleep with it and then spit it out and is ok other times (i.e. naps and first 1/2 of night).
Thanks again for your input,
Karel