you know Deb i seriously think there is some other reason for his night wakings, like perhaps going to him too soon or something? They do wake up, can for hours but if you dont go to them they know go back to sleep
Just weird to have them this long in length and for this long. I think perhaps the issues are not even related
Does he cry, upset upset cry? When do you go to him, how do you know hes awake? Do you use a monitor and hear him? Perhaps you go to soon, or atleast used to and set up a expectation
deb, i hope i am not sticking my nose in where things don't belong. i have been reading along now for many pages (i still check up on fellow 2-1nappers). what stacy is saying here really hit home for me regarding your problems with noah.
i think noah is still in a crib..... if he is not, please correct me of course.
my avery is on a solid one nap situation now, but we recently had a problem with this. my little non-waker was suddenly waking and not being very nice about it. please note, we are in a big bed. i probably did go in to her faster than i would in a crib, because at first i was a touch worried that she'd try getting out of bed. i guess it was all good intentions, but really, it took her like three days of me coming in to her (where i wouldn't have before) before she started to fly off the handle. some days, it happened at naptime and bedtime....sometimes middle of the night. it was random enough at first to throw me for a loop.
anyways, we have solved that problem now. it really did take me doing just about everything---i asked all the questions OT?, A times not long enough, too short----geez, i went nutso! then my harsh reality was that my toddler had learned how to pull mommy's strings---i was her puppet!!
it wasn't fun to fix. it took a few days of really hard work and very repetitive work to get it solved. actually, in as many days as it took her to catch on, it took her that long to get off the crap she was up to. we had a super yucky afternoon nap, followed by screaming at bedtime for an hour, then one completely blown off nap. my husband could not believe her level of intensity---her screaming was very on purpose and very tantrummy---she wanted mom in that room!
fingers crossed, it stopped for us right there. it took us a few days, but she once again started to wake in the night on her own and settle on her own. we really had NEVER had problems with this......
she will now lay in bed and wait for mom or dad to come. At first, it was short amounts (i truly believe she lost trust in us somehow) and now she will wake in the night, sometimes for 1hr-2hrs (odd, but she does) and stay in bed the whole time and go back to sleep. I also try to give her way more credit than i was.....on a few occasions, i have heard her wake/move around every hour and resettle. I think at their age, this age, they really come into their own with sleep.
I follow Stacy's advice when we have an early wakeup. I know that Avery will probably need to go down sooner and may need to nap longer, but i can't control those things necessarily.
If Avery wakes at 630am (730am is our usual), i try not to overanalyze it. I leave her in bed for as long as she is happy, or 730am. She woke 1hr early, split that time in half, put her down to nap about 1/2hr earlier than normal. Since she woke early, i 'might' even let her sleep till 2.25hrs if she is lucky/or if i am lucky and she is still sleeping. But bedtime generally stays at 730pm....we do put down earlier if she just seems to need to go.
I do know one thing that has helped me loads----i USED to think that if Avery napped only 1.25hrs, she might need to go to bed at the 5hr mark. Overtime i realized, that her nap length seems to not matter about bedtime so much like it used to.....so a 1.75hr nap vs a 1hr nap don't leave her spiralling out of control. And she seems to still fall asleep at the same time no matter what. BUT she never wakes at the same time everyday and she still has nw'ings for no reason at all. I've come to learn that she is doing what she needs to. AND really, we all have our unexplainable grouchy days!
I hope this helps deb. I think Noah is doing all he can. Every time you write out his routine, i can't see any faults really by him or you. I think it's time to trust him a little more than you are....
relax! You will have another baby soon. You won't have time for all this.
hth
Sami