hey hun,, hope you dont mind but,,,
dont you think that your giving your lo mixed signals? you took an hour to get her to sleep alone,, which was fab hun and i think you and baby done well,, then you never gave in,, took 3 hours to put her back to sleep,,more than i could have handled anyway,, but you did stick with it,, but then the next time dd woke you took he to bed with you!,,, so,,will you not have wasted 4 hours by doing so,, because,, you taught her to sleep alone,, but then took her out again,, therfor unteaching her.
i know this is easy for me to say hun,, ive not been living this,, im not the one who has had no sleep like you and im sorry if i sound negative as i dont wish to. you asked if one hour was good,, i think it was great,, a well done job.
i know that you feel that gradually removal will do best but have you thought of doing pu/pd,, or wi.wo,, or the method you are using just now,, sitting with her till she falls over(and doing a fab job at) for 5 days or so,, to see if it works? if it doesnt hun,, go back to gw,, you have nothing to loose,, but do it all at once,, i mean the way it says in the book,, rather than gw.
sshh your dd in the night may actually be what has kept her up longer,, it may be whats stimulating her and keeping her up,, i do know that if i do this with kacey,, she thinks its morning time,, time to get up as she sees me as instagating a convercation when i do sshh,, thats why i have to be there in the room,, or hand on her back,, or wi/wo without saying a word!
i know you keep saying about props,,, but i dont see any really (because you are doing sleep training),, apart from the paci,,, i know you dont want to remove this prop hun,, but its kinda a huge probem and will continue to be one,, not because its a paci,, because youyr dd wakes for it to be put back in,, and you cant teach her to re plug iut herself,, she will learn that herself,, and some kids dont,, so the paci is not doing teh job that its intended to do. you could do sleep training,, 2 weeks of long hard work,, then have to do all over again when you remove the paci,, kinda giving yourself double work here. can you not ditch the paci when your doing the sleep traing?
i would just like to add that i think,, as you already know,, that you are one of the most fab mothers on here,, with the pacience of a saint hun,, i dont want you to think that im critisisng you in any way,, love kerry