Sorry you're feeling disheartened, Rachael. I do think you're making progress though, don't you? When was your last pre-5 a.m. wake-up?

I am so fed up with early bedtimes (for me) and early mornings I never see my hubby and when I do I am so exhausted I just want to sleep.
I love early bedtimes

Since DS1 (3.5 years) recently dropped his day nap, we have both boys in bed at approx 6.30 p.m. Yes, I practically collapse in exhaustion from running around after 2 toddlers all day, and I need an early bedtime too, but I have a lot more time in the evening with DH than most ppl I know. My brother has 3 girls who have absolutely no routine, they just fall asleep wherever and whenever they want. Their 4 year old sometimes goes to bed as late as 11 p.m.

I know which I'd rather

But of course Maya has to fit in with your family life, too.
Has anyone asked you yet what her demeanour/behaviour is like generally? Is she a happy little girl generally or is she always tired and cranky? I would think if her bodyclock was really set on no more than 10.5 hours overnight and 1.5 hours nap then she'd be functioning pretty well and generally happy. If her behaviour is othewise then I'd definitely be trying to extend that sleep total as much as I could.
she was really happy when she woke this morning and no chance of her going back to sleep
Well, on this occasion you'd almost excuse her for the EW, wouldn't you? If she's waking happy then she's obviously on her way to catching up on sleep and I think you'll find is on her way towards stretching that nap and wake-up time out. In this event I'd almost certainly keep her up til at least 11.30 a.m. for her nap, maybe even stretch her out another 15 mins. It's all about pushing that day out, remember.
The other alternative I was going to suggest was to work at extending that nap whatever way you can. If you ultimately want a later bedtime then you have to get her napping longer and later into the afternoon. I personally can't see her doing this until she erases all that OT. JMO.
I'm sorry but there's just nothing else I can offer. You're her mummy and if your gut instinct tells you the early bedtime isn't for either of you, then see if anyone else can offer any more suggestions. I really do hope you carry on for a little while at least because I think you're both doing really well.
Btw, I think I mentioned somewhere a couple of pages ago that I'd avoid (if possible) any car trips where you think she might take a catnap which can interfere with either nap or bedtime. For a 6.30 bedtime, I would actually be serving dinner at 5 p.m. Any later and my boys are just too tired to eat. In this situation, if a car trip is unavoidable, I would be plying her with food in the car, maybe some healthy snacks so that if she didn't eat when you got home, she'd still have something nutritious in her tummy. Remember also it's not just about food, it's the DISTRACTION
