Hi there-
It's really frustrating when H's don't agree with sleep methods, especially if more often than not, they don't do the bedtime routine!
What does your day look like? Can you post a typical routine?
My lo is very spirited, so we've had to do more of a gradual withdrawl.
The key is CONSISTENCY. If you do the same thing every time your lo wakes, s/he will get the message.
Post some more info, and hopefully we'll be able to offer some advice.
In the meantime, hang in there-
Leslie