Hi Laura,
It's hard to say isn't it but if it were me, and Joseph was breaking out of his swaddle every night then I'd continue with trying the arms out (either 1 or 2). At the end of the day, it can't last forever and she will get used to it. (That's what i tell myself when I'm going through a rough time with him!!)
The only reason I decided to take him out of his swaddle was because he kept breaking free (well that and I thought he'd be 12 years old and still in a swaddle!!
![Grin ;D](https://smiley.babywhispererforums.com/Smileys/classic/grin.gif)
) and I thought that if he was breaking free then maybe it was the right time, regardless of his age.
Saying that, if you do want to hold off, I used a hippopotamus swaddle with velcro on it which used to work a treat.
I do agree with the whole 'getting them in a sleeping bag' because at the minute he's still wrapped in his swaddle, just with his arms out! Next step, bag...
![Wink ;)](https://smiley.babywhispererforums.com/Smileys/classic/wink.gif)
Plus, Joseph is off to nursery at end of April and I think they'd think Iwas bonkers if he was still swaddled!!
As ever, let me know how your getting on!! xx
Amelialove, yep I got on but never used it so far but thanks for the tip!