Hi girls! I too gave my LO apples whole at 12 mos- we went apple picking and he just helped himself- peel and all- same sort of thought that Mashi had, I guess, that the apples were so large, he just sort of gnawed on it at first- shearing off small amounts and not really "biting" a huge chunk. That being said, you know your LO's abilities and some kids aren't ready for that by 12 mos, and others are.
We also went through the, Take a HUGE bite, chew it up and SPit it out phase here too!
Love the photo!