We didn't go need to go onto Neocate, we stayed with Nutramigen, but yes, that's exactly what the poops were like and pretty much what the paed said. My husband used to race out the door in the mornings for work so as to avoid the poop smell sticking to him, as it's nasty nasty nasty! It got slightly better on early solids, and by about 9-10 months with the amount of solids he was on it was much more bearable!