So sorry, Christine! Lots of (((hugs)))!! A few things pop out at me when I read this. (Ok, ahk posted while I did, and I think we have some similar advice, but I'm still going to post in case anything helps. Sorry it's so long!)
Finally for the third nap refusal, DH picked her up and held her to sleep for 115 minutes. I told DH that this could create a habit, but he said she really needed some type of sleep. Then she went down for BT completely quietly and awake. I dont' get it. She never fights BT but naps are horrid!
I know we've been encouraging you to be careful with the AP, but I tend to agree with your DH here. She must be sooo tired! It's really a bummer you can't drive her around for a few days, because this sounds exactly like what we went through with my DD at Christmas time. It was right before she got her molars and I had tried a couple one nap days because I just didn't know what else to do, so she got really OT. We were up at my ILs for the week and she would scream every time I put her in the crib for a nap, so we'd end up taking her out for a drive. But, when I went to lay her down for BT, she went in like a charm and was asleep within minutes. It really is strange! But I think that nap Sophie got with your DH was enough to take just the edge off the OT, so she went down well for BT.
5:30 Wake
9:30 Try to put her down for a nap and it's 1010 and she's still fighting it.
So, this is really OT refusal, I think, because she had really been up since 4:30 am. And with the missed naps yesterday and a short night, the OT is just building up. With teeth (+ a little OT), when I'm off by just 15 min with my DD, she can have a hard time settling. It happened last night at bedtime (took 30 mins of on/off screaming, mantraing) and today at nap (took 15 mins of the same). It's so hard to go through, and I kick myself for getting her in bed late, but sometimes no matter how hard I try, she is able to drag it out a little.
I think I would have tried to put her down more at 8:30 or 8:45 am here. Because she has had a couple naps here and there that have been successful, I do think she can do it.
I knew she had pain meds, but she just really wanted me. Plus I think it was bad because I never went in before, it was always my DH that did it.
DH thinks WIWO won't work after hearing her frantic this morning, so he thought I should go in and sit there like GW again but I think since she knows how to go down, I don't htink I should change it.
So, I think you have a couple options at this point. I really don't think it should matter who is doing the WIWO; she may have to get used to you doing it, but if you're consistent, it should be fine. However, if she is really struggling with her teeth and a fever and SA, then I might be tempted to try GW. Yes, I know she
does know how to do it, but she's having a really tough time and it's been at least a week with not much improvement. My DD doesn't do well when I'm in the room, even if she's frantically screaming for me. Once I'm there she just wants to interact and it makes the whole process longer. But, it may be worth a try in your case. I think she's taking so long to settle because she's pretty OT, but there are other things involved which makes it harder.
Lastly, you may just give in to doing whatever you can to get her some sleep for the next few days, even if it means some AP. If only the car would work for you, that's what I'd be doing for sure. I know this is probably anti-BW advice, but once she isn't so OT, I think she'll probably respond to WIWO (or GW for that matter) better. It may be harder when you start again, so it may not be worth it. But, she's got to be just extremely tired at this point.