Well, we went to the breastfeeding clinic. The nurse stuck her fingers in DD's mouth, and I watched her. She said her sucking reflex was great, her tongue was fine, and there was no reason why we can not breastfeed.
HOWEVER... what I was doing wrong: because of my "geography" of my nipples (haha! I almost giggled at this when she said it lol) I had to shift DD a little to get her to latch correctly. Also, I was shown how to hold my breast wrong. As soon as I changed those two little things ta-da! No more lipstick nipple! I almost cried. Another big HOWEVER is DD is a refluxer, AS I SUSPECTED in the first place. I had issues in the bottle department, (theres a thread of mine in the bottle forum) and suspected DD had all sorts of classic reflux symptoms and I have brought it up many-a-time with 3 different doctors and a nurse and none seemed unconcerned. This nurse spotted it off the get go, and I almost cried again because I couldn't shake the feelings that something was not right with DD. She said because DD doesn't cry after feeding, as long as I manage her reflux (changing diapers before feedings, holding her over my shoulder after feedings, among a few other things) medication is not nessecary. Yes, DD is uncomfortable, its very apparent, but it isn't too bad. It will just take time.
Gosh, I'm so proud of myself. And I'm so happy to have your ladies' support
. I'm half tempted to discard/donate all my bottles to other pregnant mamas. Although I think I'll keep one or two for flexibility should I want to go out.