I guess it's just hard when you've been spoilt the first time round and DS1 is such a good sleeper from me doing EASY with him early.
For sure... just know that what you're experiencing now really isn't that abnormal or bad, although I know how nice STTN is.
I really hoping I can resolve without having to take her paci because I read its soothing and helpful for reflux babies.
Yes, that's why I didn't even mention it. Soon and with lots of practice, she should be able to learn how to replug herself, and then it is no longer a prop, but a comfort item. And, yes she may need it to transition naps at this point, but she may grow out of that as well, and as long as she's not constantly waking up for it at night, I wouldn't worry too much about it. I also meant to mention earlier that PUPD isn't suggested for reflux babies of this age as it can aggravate the reflux, so you don't have to worry about that. You also don't need to do shh/pat if it bothers her... just need to find something that helps to soothe her, like stroking her forehead or patting/rubbing the thigh, etc.
I think you've got a good plan with gently pushing out the A times.