And definitely not Vicki, you can teach granny to suck eggs anytime as it seems I have no clue when it come to my own LO!!
And there in lies the essence of this forum lol
it does get easier though, honest! (at least with sleep while other issues take over
)
It just occurred to me that although she is resisting BT many of the issues that go along with sleep resistance usually she just seems to skip, like every day grumpiness (she chooses to sing instead) EW with no resettle (she stays in her cot, and sometimes resettles! is that right?)
So I guess the things that need addressing are nap time and length to suit her best, and minimise BT shenanigans.
As she doesn't like being woken from her nap, I would say if you decide to cut it back, then go with the softly softly approach (if you can stand it) and cut an extra 5 mins at a time. Have her favourite snack and TV programme at the ready to distract all you can.
Because this does kinda smell of development, in some part at least I'd say, it could be dangerous to cut the nap back any more at the moment I guess, in case you are 'over fixing' what isn't broken :/.
I'm wondering if you could maybe approach this in a ST way, with WI/WO. Not in order to stimulate her brain whenever you go back in, but just to let her know 'Mammy is still 'with you' and help transition to sleep, without her feeling the need to 'call back.' If she's not upset maybe stick to every 5 mins or so. Hash out all of the reasons for call backs before she goes down if you can (BTDT) then don't indulge her, unless she has a soiled nappy.
So looking at something like this:
WU: 6.30
Nap: 12.45 - 2.00 capped (distract with terrible family singing upon WU
)
In bed by 7.15 (maybe try the audio stories instead of white noise?)
Then tell her Mammy will be back, and do WI/WO every 5 mins or so.
The reason I'm suggesting this is to play to her personality and what is going on developmentally. I wonder if the reason she is not sleeping quickly with such a short nap is because her little brain can't switch off and she is finding it difficult to give up the contact/human stimulation, so in doing WI/WO initially and offering an audio story she may rest easier.
There is every chance this may be a ridiculous idea lol, but sometimes a little bit of straw clutching can pay off
x.