I totally agree with Deb. I was so adamant about having DS2 on EASY right from the get go but when he was diagnosed with reflux and he wasn't/still isn't really gaining weight, I had to modify things. I mostly fed on demand and I wore him quite a bit to keep him upright his feeds. Is it possible that instead of being tired, he's just bored with whatever you're doing in that moment? I remember Tracey mentioning that. My DS2 can now handle a 4hr EASY so here it is, as you requested:
WU & E: 7:30 (I always change his diaper as soon as wakes, so I don't have to lay him down after he's eaten)
A: 7:45
S: 9:30 (Sometimes he's in his crib, sometimes he's in the ERGO. I'm usually able to transfer him once we get home)
Y: Play with DS1
WU: 11/11:30
E: 11:30
A:11:45
S:1:30
Y: Read, sit in total silence while both children sleep!
WU: 3
E:3
A:3:15
S: 5
WU:5:30/5:45 (depends on his naps for the day)
E: 5:45/6
Bath & stories with BB: 6:30
E: 7ish
S:7:10
If DH is home he's asleep by 7. I added in the WU's because sometimes he wakes before it's time to eat and I wanted you to get an accurate picture. At the moment I'm testing out 2hrs and 5mins because he was getting really fussy as I lay him down, making me think he's ready for a slow A push.