My DS is only 2 months old so I'm certainly not an expert but this is what we did:
Before starting the Shhh/pat, we struggled for a few weeks getting him to sleep in his crib and I don't think we even had any bad patterns to break, we were just inconsistent.
1. Swaddle
2. Sit in rocking chair...don't rock. Started with having him nuzzle into my chest so I could get to his back and Shhhh/pat when he was crying/kicking. At that point the pacifier also channeled his sleep fighting energy into sucking. Eventually he preferred laying in my arms looking up and rarely needed a shhh/pat there. Sometimes I held his hand or put my hand on his chest as extra comfort
3. When his eyes got really heavy and closed for a bit I would put him in his crib (I waited until his eyes were closed for a bit because it got him extra relaxed and he still opened his eyes when I placed him in the crib to know he was there)
4. I stood for just a few seconds to make sure he was settled and then sat on a stool next to the crib so that I was out of his sight. If he needed it, I would drape my arm over the crib and shhh, pat when he started crying. If he really got crying I would pick him up, but he most often settled down with the shhh/pat and pacifier. I would continue the Shhh/pat after he stopped and then stop the shhh...but keep patting....then stop patting. (Eventually he got to the point where I rarely shhhed, and I just put my hand on his chest with no patting.)
5. I would sit there for a very long time to catch the jolt..or to start over ...sometimes this whole process took up to an hour. I kept my sanity by starting a good thriller book as I sat on the stool. Once he appeared to be in a deep sleep I would leave the room.
After about 3 weeks of this I'm happy to report that we now swaddle, sit in a chair for 10-15 minutes, put down in crib (sometimes eyes closed but awake, sometimes with eyes open) and then walk out of the room.
I was concerned about the pacifier being a prop but just when I think he is relying on me too much to put the pacifier in his mouth when he wakes up, he'll change and not need it for that nap. So..I'm not worrying about the pacifier anymore.
Also...we stayed consistent and never resorted to any other method. It got really frustrating at times (lots of tears on my part) but having a plan with your husband to relieve each other helps a lot.
I hope that helps!