Hi there,
Sorry to hear you're having such a rough time. I know what it's like. I too used to bf my ds to sleep and then struggled to help him become an independent sleeper. I used a combination of pu/pd and pat/shhh and the gentle removal plan. Here's a great link from this site that has tons of info n the gentle removal plan.
http://www.babywhisperer.com/forum/gentle-removal-plan-vt24669.htmlIt seems like you had some success with the pu/pd for her nap today. I know it can be difficult at first, but if you are conisistent, it WILL pay off. It is tempting to cave in and bf her to sleep, but it will be too confusing to your little one. She will think, 'what's going on here? Mom gave me the boob for the last nap, why not now?!' It isn't fair for them. It will take some time, but is definitely worth it. It is a gradual and gentle method, which is what really appealed to me - no huge changes too quickly for our little ones.
Another thing that really helped me was listening for his 'I need you now!' cry. I would leave the room after laying him down and let him settle while listening. Tracy calls this S.L.O.W. - stop, listen, observe, what's up?....I think (it's been awhile since I had to read her book). This is NOT the same as cry it out. It's just allowing them to settle themselves without rushing in.
I wouldn't introduce a pacifier at this stage in the game if she's finding other ways of soothing herself. The pacifier would just be one more thing to wean her off of. :roll:
I hope this helps somewhat. Sorry it's all over the place. Gotta go rinse the hair colouring out of my hair! :oops:
Let us know how things are going.