Yes, it makes sense and I agree. It's not the times that are tripping me up, it's the night wakings - their frequency and the fact that the book advises to feed her more during the day, but I can't seem to get anymore into her at each meal, even when I have stopped the snacking (bottles) in between and kept the naps consistent. She ate great at lunch again, but it eventually ended in tears.
It took me a couple of weeks to get her into this 2 X 1.5 hr nap routine, and it was one thing I could count on as consistent. Then this weekend she changed it and now I'm hearing that I should let her skip the afternoon and either extend the morning one, make it shorter too, or make it a little later.
By bedtime she is exhausted, but that hasn't changed the night wakings either, it's just made it easier to put down.
Keep the ideas coming, Girls!