Charlotte, I had to laugh.....

Our EASY is all over the place, that's why I was asking Kerrie about the 2-1 switch.
We have about 3 different things that we do. It depends on how tired he seems in the morning.
Our average wake up time right now is 5:30 AM

So I think it's time to push things to one nap. I pushed for 1 nap yesterday and today. Yesterday went great.
Wake 6:15
Refused first nap

So ended up doing 4h25m of A time before I had him in the crib. Took him about 10 minutes to go to sleep.
Woke at 1h30m.... and I actually got him to go back to sleep. He was standing up and crying. The whole nine yards and I still got him back to sleep by just lightly holding him down and SHHHHH really loudly

He slept another hour.
So nap was about 11:10-1:40
We had kindermusick so I couldn't put him down until 7:15 but he went down without a fuss.
However, he was up between 4:30-6, but I didn't have to go to him at all, it was sort of weird. But then he slept until 7:45am this morning, so go figure.
Today was a bust, of sorts.
He only napped 1h15m between 11:20-12:35
He was in a pretty good mood though for most of the day. He was doing bedtime avoidance of book after book after book, it's hard for me to say no to reading more to him, it's my only cuddle time I get all day. It blows me away that he is smart enough already to manipulate this.
But otherwise sometimes we do 2 naps of about 1h15m with about 3h15m A time in between everything
And I've been really trying to do the 20 min morning nap. I know some moms on here who have had a ton of success with this, but it is just not working for me at all.
When I do this I do about
3h15-3h30m A time
20 min nap
2 hours A time
nap anywhere from 1h10m-2h20m
3-4 hours A time.
Something that worked well when Lyle was about Charlie's age was
3h30m A time-4 hours A time
45min nap
3h10m A time
Nap of 1h30m-2 hours
4 hours A time
That worked really really well for us. for awhile
Every few days in there I had one nap days. A time about 4h-4h15m and I had some really good naps.
I hope that makes sense and helps a little. Feel free to ask me any more questions. I've read a lot about the 2-1 switch and I'm currently on the 2-1 nap thread. So I hear what others are doing, it's a big topic on the BC for this age too.