Hiya!
I too read the no cry sleep solutions. Alot of Pantley's concepts are similar to Tracy's, as she doesn't think babies should be left to fighure stuff out on their own either. We even use her Gentle Removal Plan for paci and breast. However we are not really well versed in her methods and solutions.
I think if you want to pull parts of Pantley into your parenting, that is great. But I also think the parts you tried that failed and messed things up - well that is in the past now. What's important now, is that Stacy has laid out a great plan for you and your baby - and now is the time to put what she has said into action and give it a try. You won't know if its going to work, unless you have at it and stick with it for 2 weeks. Stick with it ALL the way, not half or just parts - its a plan, and needs to be done a certain way to work correctly.
The stressed points here are commitment - to one plan, to one way, for as long as it takes. And consistency - to one plan, each time you do it, for as long as it takes.
Here is a success story I think my help you:
https://babywhispererforums.com/index.php?topic=67630.0 - here we set a plan up for a similar situation and she had fabulous results.
Good Luck Hun, don't be afraid - we have so many successes here with these methods - they work if you keep at them.
Zoey