Hi there! Congratulations on your little one!
It sounds like his short naps might be caused by being overtired. Have you tried shortening his awake time? I definitely notice that my LO takes a 30 min nap when he is overtired.
Also, I have found that my LO wakes at night when he is overtired during the day. I would try doing whatever I could to get some good sleep in during the day, especially naps longer than an hour - it is more restful. I had to shh/pat to get mine to sleep longer at times.
Have you ever tracked the total number of hours he sleeps per day? I started doing that, figured out what he needed for a good day, and then worked towards getting that.
I definitely wouldn't feed him at night, unless you know he's hungry. That will just encourage him to wake more to eat b/c he'll eat less during the day.
If you think you could wean the paci, you might try that. It sounds like it could be a prop. He's young, though. I don't know for sure on that.
I also thought that he would eat more at his feedings if he were more alert. I'm sure you have thought of that!
Is there a reason you have him on a 3 1/2 hour feeding schedule rather than a 3? Not that it's bad; I was just curious. It sounds like he is doing well taking the dream feed and really not needing another feed till morning, so it's fine, I'm sure.
I wanted to share with you an experience I had. I don't give a dream feed b/c I think it makes my LO wake more at night, but for a while, I also didn't feed him at all during the night (a couple of nights in a row, he'd wake, we'd give paci, go make a bottle, and by the time we were back, he was asleep, so we thought he didn't need to eat). What happened was that he started every hour, we'd give the paci, and he'd go back to sleep. But that is brutal! No sleep for us! One night I decided to feed him just to see what would happen, and he ate 8 ounces and slept the rest of the night. I don't necessarily think yours is waking due to hunger. I just share that with you so that you can keep a couple of things in mind. One is the dream feed - I've talked to other people who have said that the dream feed made their LO wake more. I also just wanted you to consider that hunger CAN cause a LO to wake, but it's not always the cause. Tracy says habitual waking is not due to hunger, but random wakings can be.
I really think the most important thing is to get him to bed after a well rested day.
I promise it will get better.
Hope something I said helps.
Hugs to you.
Brooke