Good evening, fussy mom!
Try not to stress...you will both figure this out...we are not born with parenting skills..we have to learn..just like they do.
I agree...if he is content...and not crying...just let him be...he will soon learn to got back to sleep on his own.
Sounds like you are both tired during the day and used to being awake at night.
When I first started getting my little one to sleep on her own, I did shh/pat in her crib. She was very stimulated by light and everything visual. So when I was doing shhh/pat, I would turn her face away from mine but having her on her side facing the wall, if she was settled in her crib on her back, instead of moving her on those occasions I would hold my hand over her eyes to block out visual stimulation and so that she could not make eye contact with me.
It sounds like he's starting to enjoy the interaction with you while you are working through this with the shh/pat... Remember that you are there to help him only. I would try not to stop the shh and the pat at the same time...It could be that you are stopping the shh/pat too early.
This is what my shh/pat process looked like when I started, if it helps...
-wakes...fusses...leave her along
-fussing changes to crying...go into her bedroom, turn her onto her side, pat her back, shh her until her crying stops
-continue pat and shh for another 5 minutes, listening for breathing sounds that indicate she is relaxing back into sleep
-stop pat, continue shh for another 5 minutes
-if she has not started to fuss again, leave her in her crib and in her room.
I think Tracy's book says that it takes around 15 minutes for them to get into a deeper sleep cycle so I would often keep an eye on my watch while I was in there.
One more question...do you find he is always waking at 1 in the morning? Or is it not always by the clock?
Leanne