Thing is hun, if you end up replugging her I would stop trying to do shush pat or PUPD because you're not getting anything from it. You're not accomplishing anything. Remember, BW isn't a 'no cry' technique, and as Bec has said, as long as you're there with her no harm will come to her. I think you really have to decide whether you're going to replug her, or whether your'e going to stop, or whether you're just going to wean the paci, and then stick with it. Like I said, no point trying to soothe her for 40 mins and then still end up replugging her.