Thank you for your replies. The testimonies from other success stories has helped reassure me so I did try the shh / pat again this morning. It took awhile but not as painful. From my previous attempts, the patting and shh'ing alone would not soothe my DD so I found another way which was to rub her chest / tummy in a circular motion and patting gently on her shoulder while sshh. I didn't realize I was that coordinated
but whatever works for my DD. My DD was able to settle down and fall asleep but they were brief so every time she woke up and cried, I would do the ssh / pat / rub again.
hannahbanana - you so right about giving my DD 'props' before laying her in bed. I would rock her to get her drowsy but awake, even after seeing her yawn. I would also give her the pacifier because that was the only way I can soothe her until the pacifier falls out and that would make her mad. So next time around, I'll try not to give her the pacifier too quickly because I can see already she will become dependent on it to fall asleep. I also won't rock but just hold her briefly before laying her down.