Teething pain seems to come in bouts of 3/4 nights for us so we medicated for that time and then stopped and saw how the next few nights went. I tried homeopathic remedies at times but didn't find they did much for my two, I know some people find them really good. I also didn't medicate in the day so I knew they weren't being over medicated if they had meds for several nights in a row. I used to give ibuprofen at bedtime when they had full tummies and a dream med of acetaminophen/ paracetamol.
I know it's hard medicating babies but as an adult I know toothache is one of the worst things so I figured if I medicate myself for that pain then I wanted to make sure my babies were as comfortable as possible too.
Laura