what is she into? does she love building, dress up, pretend play, outdoorsy things? Is she into animals, arts and crafts, adventure?
Last year Nick got a tuxedo, so that's not much help

and yes, it was on HIS list...go figure.
I love having craft kits to pull out on snowy days. a new sled, swimming lessons over the winter at an indoor pool, kids' magazine subscription, window sill garden, legos/playmobil, ... hmmm. thinking ....