Thank you for the replies, I am getting better at reading what works for him, it really depends on his moods, sometimes only holding and sh/pat works, sometimes just patting in the crib works best. The other thing is it is really hard to get him to do the catnaps. He normally spends the whole time with me trying to settle him and him crying. Do I just dispense witht he catnaps altogether? They are very short and he just won't settle in that time. I have a feeling it is just too much sleep for him. The length of sleep time on 3hr EASY just seems so much, especially after the very limited amount he used to get in the day.