Hi again, I'm back, as promised to comment on Grant's post. Kids are both napping so have a little bit of time.
So, Grants, wanted to share with you a link that's been recommended to me several times, but I haven't gotten the chance to get her book. Just thought if you wanted to tinker with other methods besides BW that also suits our philosophies of not letting our los CIO, you might want to try the "Australian Babywhisperer".
http://www.australianbabywhisperer.com.au/ Just from a personal perspective, most of everything I've read out there (and I've read a lot), are so generic and didn't offer much with regards to real useful strategies that we don't already use with BW. It seems they were saying a lot of the same things that BW did, and the other extreme was CC or CIO, which is not for me. But I heard that the Aussie BW has some concrete steps that might be worth looking into...
But, to your questions about allergies... the first red flag for us was the fact that he had so many NWs to the point that I felt it was a bit "abnormal", especially for a baby that was already sleep trained. But, you are right in that I did see reactions. Hives, mostly, on skin. At first, I thought his skin was just sensitive. Sometimes it was just red, othertimes, little bumps, and other times, there were very obvious hives. But, I couldn't isolate the cause no matter how much I controlled HIS diet. Then realized the other variable (which is my diet) was not controlled. So talked with my ped, and he ran a blood panel which then confirmed that he was allergic to those foods and was getting exposed through BM. Plus, he's allergic to cats, and we have a cat at home, too, who liked to sleep right next to his crib!
From the sound of things, if you are not seeing any kind of reaction, then it's probably safe to rule out food-related allergies.
But, I really believe from the bottom of my heart that this WILL pass. I do think 2-1 transition is tough for them at this age. Plus the teething, plus the developmental milestones. If your lo is settling with teething gel, he is probably bothered by that. And other times bothered by something else, like the 2-1. It's hard to pin it down when there are so many things that can cause the NWs at this age. That's why I think 18 months is that magic number. They should be down to 1 nap by then, and should have a full set of teeth by then, and they can... ta da... verbalize!!
Anyway have either of you, (inoella, too) thought about w2s as a strategy? Once you start looking at your sleep diary, there might be some time frames where it's definitely habitual. Our los might have some times that are habitual wakings and other times that are wakings due to teeth, etc. So, when you add it all up, maybe it ends up being 5 NWs? In fact, Inoella, you might think of w2s as a way to wean from night feeding. Catch them before they wake up, so to speak...
Good luck, inoella in the 2-1 transition. It looks like you have several issues going on. But, here's something to consider. Even if you transitioned to 1 nap, it won't necessarily fix the NWs if your lo is waking at night to nurse, kwim? So, while you are working on 2-1 transition, you might gradually drop the night feeds as you get a handle on the solids, and try to get her more filled up that way. At 9 months, they need more solids than milk, particularly they need iron. So, you are definitely on that course of trying to flip the eating from more solids and less milk. If your milk supply drops naturally because she is eating more, let that be your biological "window" to allow the night feeds to drop, too. Then use pd, sh/pt, or w2s to help your lo ride out the habitual nursing.
I hope that things at nursery goes well, Grants. It's great that they are willing to sit down with you and talk about your routine. I'm sure your lo will do fine. He seems like such a great little boy.
My little guy had 4 NWs last night. And for once, I can DEFINITELY say this is due to teeth. Sore bottom, drooling, fingers in mouth all the time, biting. I might have to give him some pain meds 30 minutes before bed and see what happens.