Hey there, back again now
Sorry, re-reading, you'd already said that she wasn't sleeping independently when I asked you again
Ok, great that you're reading to tackle this and that DH is supporting you - hope you enjoy your 7h tonight
So, she does seem likely to be quite OT to me, and this may well increase as she has to learn a new way to get herself to sleep, but once she's sleeping better she should be able to settle into a routine and start to get less OT
I'm sure you're already aware that it'll be hard work, with setbacks along the way, but well worth it. Also if you can give her as many opportunities as possible to learn, she should learn more quickly - but i appreciate that with dd1 at home you may sometimes just have to get out and let her nap in the car. And at least then if she takes a good nap there, that will help stop some of the build up of OT, so it's not all bad
So, to clarify - what have you been trying so far? From what you posted, it sounds like you've been using a variation of shh pat (by all means play around to find what's most soothing for her) to get her to fall asleep in her cot, rather than in your arms? All I can say is that if on day 1, she's been able to do that within 30mins, you can count that a big success
Are you patting her (etc) all the way to sleep, or just until she's starting to settle herself? Don't worry if it's all the way to sleep to begin with, it's a big step from going to sleep in your arms to going to sleep in the cot. But as she gets used to this, you can start reducing the amount and duration of the help you're giving her - the end goal at this stage would be to be able to put her down at the end of her wind down routine and have her settle herself to sleep without any further intervention from you. That might seem a way off, but you may be surprised at the progress she makes
Other things that can help are having a dark room (mine needed pitch black as very distracted by visual stuff!), white noise (can muffle other sounds as well as soothe) and a consistent wind down routine.
Thinking about your daily routine - I'm looking back at the first EASY you posted for clues, would you say that her first A time when she was napping in your arms was 2.5h and she slept for 1.5h? Or was it more like 2h? Whatever it was, that might be a good place to start when you're trying for a nap in the cot, but perhaps bring it a little earlier, say, 15mins perhaps, as it'll take a little longer for her to actually fall asleep. When she takes a short nap, if you're able to try and resettle, that would also really help her - easier said than done, I realise. With another LO around, it's obviously a juggling act. I personally used to creep out of the room as soon as I could (for us, I actually had to stay in for the first 20mins or so until she'd reached deep sleep, otherwise the floorboards creaking would wake her
but you may be able to 'escape' sooner), and then wait until she woke, give her a few moments to ascertain whether she was crying an 'I need you' cry and then return to the room and do all the same settling stuff that I did at the beginning of the nap, keeping her in the cot if possible. Sometimes that worked, but I'd set a time limit (depending on how DS was doing etc) and if she hadn't settled by then, I'd give up and take her out of the room and feed if she was ready. Tracy would suggest a period of 45mins to settle at the beginning of the nap - if no sleep reached by then, take them out of the room for 5mins or so for quiet cuddles and then back in to try again. For resettling a short nap, try up to 45mins before giving up, or sooner if dd1 needs you. (DS got through a few DVDs during this phase for us
) Just be aware that if she short-naps (anything less than 1.5h is generally not considered restorative, although the third nap is commonly a CN at this age), you'll need to reduce the next A time a little to avoid OT. Oh, and try to log everything if possible, that way we can see how things are progressing and perhaps make some better guesses as to appropriate A times.
About the teat size - no experience here but by all means follow your mummy instincts
I'm hoping that getting some more daytime sleep in there and sleep training will help with those nights, but can't help wondering if there may be some discomfort going on too? I see she's started solids, can I ask how much she's having and for how long has she had them? As I'm sure you're aware, it's not generally recommended before 6mo and then just very small amounts, building up slowly - I do appreciate that all LOs are different and you may have been advised to start solids early, but they can cause problems for tiny tummies to begin with, until their digestive systems mature, so do watch for clues as to whether her solids might be causing any discomfort, especially if for example a new food has recently been introduced.
Sorry I feel I'm rambling, please feel free to ask any questions
but for now, a couple of links:
Starting E.A.S.Y. at Four Months or Older (Note - Tracy talks about PUPD here, but if shh pat is working then we'd advise you to stick with that and only go to PUPD as a last resort. Also, I'm not going to suggest that you take two days out now for observation, since you've already started the sleep training process, so I wouldn't want to confuse her, but nonetheless, you can be asking yourself those questions as she suggested, you've already sketched out your DD's routine for us)
Shush-pat - How to