does this mean I shouldn't sing to him or do anything to calm him down? I am trying but its really hard to see him cry like that.
(((Hugs))), I know it isn't easy. You can of course sing/speak to him and still use your touch (rubbing his leg or bum) to help him calm (although touch can wind them up at this age too). The key is to gradually reduce that once he's calming so that he ends up doing the work of falling asleep by himself.
I need some help with an issue that has been turning into a pattern over the past week. His first night waking is fine .. I feed him n hes right back to sleep. However the second night waking is like he wakes up to play n does not want to sleep n will be chatting n babbling amongst some crying. Last night I even fed him but he still wouldn't sleep!!
This sounds like he's UT, which is supported by your EASY in your first post. He's getting quite a bit of daytime sleep for his age and likely needs a cut to one of the naps. Did you read through the link that Noa posted on starting the 2-1 nap switch? We'd be happy to help you adjust your EAS to get it working better for you.
Also sometimes he will wake up crying n have his eyes closed? At this point do I try to settle or not?
I would just stand back and see. If it's a mantra type cry and he's still trying to sleep, I'd leave him. Even if it's an escalating mantra, but his eyes are still closed and he's trying to sleep, I'd stand back and wait. Intervene and try to help him settle when he's really doing an 'I need help here!' cry and is awake looking for you.
Katie80 how long did it take for him to start lying down by himself?
The first night, it took him about 2.5hr to finally lie down and stay down and go to sleep. The second and third night it took about an hr. And, after that he didn't wake.
Do you think he would do better in his own room? Hes still in with us! Has anyone got any experience with moving rooms making a difference?
I don't have personal experience, but I do think it can make a difference at this age. Some of his wakings might be due to you and your DH moving and shuffling about and him stirring and waking. I've seen a few LOs on here start sleeping more soundly once they are in their own rooms.
HTH!