Thank you all so much for following my never-ending saga- I really appreciate all of your insights and support.
Are you kidding?! We all need support! That is what this site is for!

Here's how it went today:
4:11am Awake
B2S from 5:50am-6:22am
9:15am-10:30am Nap 1
1:10pm I started wind down, and she began to fight me... (despite a yawn at 1pm, and a little eye rubbing), so I gave her another 15 mins. Still no go. She finally went to sleep at 2:30pm (4 hours after last nap) and slept 40 mins til 3:10pm. Was she OT or UT for this nap??
6:15pm aimed for bedtime, not asleep til about 6:30pm
Yay! A decent nap! It is hard to say if she was OT or UT yet because she is generally lacking sleep. Sometimes one nap will improve before another. It is great that you got the morning one extended. Once you have her on a routine, her naps may extend on their own but if not, you can work on lengthening with "wake to sleep."
My next questions-
**Should I have tried to put her to bed earliery tonight? I didn't think she'd go to sleep with <3 hours A time.
You know her best. If she wasn't showing signs of tiredness, I think you did fine. She seems to have gone down pretty well - only 15 minutes to sleep.
**If she has a good morning nap, do I need to move the afternoon nap later than 1:20pm? And if so, how much later?
You may end up adjusting the times of her naps once she gets over this OT state. For example, if she sleeps in later in the morning, her morning nap might get pushed back a bit and then her afternoon one a bit. I think right now stick to this routine for a week or so like MommaHolmes suggests.
**What happens when she starts waking at a reasonable hour in the morning (e.g. 6am). What time is the first nap?
May be 10 am or 10:30 am...it will depend on how late she pushes her morning wake ups.
I feel like I'm living a soap opera.
Know what you mean...As the DD Turns...hehe *Hugs*