Jenn - Fish oil, we use Ascenta's Nutrasea. Ds1 takes 1tsp/day DH and I take 1 tbsp. I've also heard amazing things about Krill Oil. Dr. Mercola talks about it alot.
I don't take nut/seed oil so I can't comment on that. I just eat a lot of nut/seed butters (almond and sunflower seed mainly)
We do Ddrops for the boys. Personally I would continue them, especially through the winter.
I also take a Cal/Mag supplement. The ones I'm using right now are by Sisu, but tbh I grab whatever I can find on sale that is Calcium Citrate. Since we aren't on any dairy, I feel it's very important.. it also makes a huge difference in my milk supply. I take between 2,000 iu/day - 3,000 iu/day. (higher dose if AF is in town )
Fenugreek - not sure
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ebea8/ebea865b2a4042d5188bd697d413610b3184c5d4" alt="Undecided :-\"
Megan can maybe comment, I know she was taking some for a while. I was taking it when Ds2 was first born b/c I wanted to be sure to have enough milk for both boys, but then I realized Arthurs tummy troubles early on so I discontinued it b/c I wasn't sure if it was bothering him or not... hummmm... are you on FB Jenn? Perhaps ask about it on the GAPS FB page. I'm sure someone would know if Fenugreek is ok?
FCLO, I ordered the oil, but here's a list of all of green pastures FCLO products:
http://www.greenpasture.org/public/Products/CodLiverOil/index.cfm I've also seen the capsules on Amazon
About the HAF - you could try the Homemade HAF
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6d972/6d97223c2135ed51672da34c6ca86d7962d3663b" alt="Huh ???"
Does she really *need* the 2 oz? Have you tried just nursing her to see if that helps? Babies are FAR more efficient nursers then a pump and can always get some milk even if a pump can't seem to get any.
Also, if you're having supply issues, I know it's not "ideal" BW'ing, but seriously, nursing on demand really does help supply.. especially as you start to enter "solids" territory. What I did when Arthur was around Emily's age was I introduced one new BF where "solids" would be in EASY... In the BW for toddlers book Tracy outlines a feeding routine w/ solids on pg 122/123. That's roughly what I did with Arthur, but with BF's instead of solids. As he became hungrier, more active, and more in the "solids" zone I just increased the BFs where solids would normally be, iykwim? (and my supply increased as well b/c I was nursing more frequently) That's really helped us since we're still delaying solids. I can hardly call the couple bites he gets here and there solids
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/332da/332dab95aeb791533078bacac8db21e52d6b250d" alt="Tongue :P"
Wish I could help Karen... maybe Deb knows? She's really good with that sort of thing
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/81ab3/81ab3f0bdef50e25e31079e7aec0c663900b490c" alt="Smiley :)"
LOL, and of course as I'm writting my post Deb has posted
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/81ab3/81ab3f0bdef50e25e31079e7aec0c663900b490c" alt="Smiley :)"